
JC: The same people that I’ve
always had in
mind. I do not write primarily for a connoisseur
crowd. I have never aimed my stuff primarily at college people
— faculty or
students. I’ve always tried
to write for the general public, and have basically the
same kind of intention that Arthur Honegger did. I know my music
probably does not sound anything like Honegger’s, but I sympathize with
what he was trying to do, particularly in his orchestral works, in the
tone poems, not just in things that were very graphic in their
portrayals like Pacific 231,
or even like the Summer Pastorale
and
the Hymn of Joy. I’ve
always had the idea that music should not
just be rational or logical. I’ve always had the French ideal of
clarity, that you should be
able to listen to the music and have a general idea, through its
transparency, of how it is put together. I don’t believe in hocus
pocus and throwing dust in people’s eyes. I would rather that it
all be there, clear and transparent. I think that
everything should come basically out of the human
voice, and that’s why I’ve always tended to write in a melodic, rather
than in a percussive way. That’s why I don’t have
bloops and bleeps with long periods of silence in between, because I
believe that that cuts off communication. I think that music
should be communication, and that it should communicate not just
sounds, but feelings. So I’m writing,
primarily I think, for people that listen to music for reasons
connected with emotions. I hope that people will have
some kind of a reaction which is not just intellectual, but emotional,
too.
JC: I’m
just
giving you how the parameters of how the
thing was set up. One parameter was to feature violin and
piano, and the next one was to use as many of the available
performers as possible. The third parameter was that since
this had something to do with the treaty between Holland and the United
States, it would be nice if I could perhaps incorporate into the piece
some authentic melodies that were used by the Dutch settlers in the New
World. It was a challenge, but I did it, and it gave me a lot of
fun. I made my living for many years as the musicologist at
ASCAP, so spent a lot of time at the Lincoln Center Library reading
various things, mostly in Dutch, and locating authentic
materials. The Dutch musicologists have done a magnificent
job in that, so thanks to their work it was very easy for me to
find what I wanted, which were folk tunes like O Sacred Head, Now Wounded.
There were things that had
originally been used for secular purposes, like drinking songs, that
had wound up in slowed-down versions and with new
lyrics, used as chorales by the Dutch Protestant Church. Some of
these showed both the religious and earlier forms of these tunes.
I used the earlier in the finale of my work, so the last movement is a
fantasia on two Dutch tunes which
were probably known to the settlers in the New World. These were
tavern songs and peasant things; I did not use Dutch art music because
there were very few
of these people in the New Netherlands. The tunes were mostly
utilized
for agricultural or money-making purposes. The fact that the
Library of Congress had a woodwind quintet available plus the violinist
and pianist made me decide to make a sort of a concerto grosso out
of the work. There are sections where it’s just the violin and
piano working
together, sometimes the wind quintet works by itself, and sometimes
all of them together. It’s a
three movement work; the first two movements are all my own
material, and the third is based on those two old melodies. The
first one is known to most Dutch people as Die Burg op Zoom, and
those words were added by a Dutch historian. As a mnemonic
device, he used popular melodies of his day as a memory aide for
people to memorize his words which were about various things like
important battles of the Dutch against the Spaniards, and so
forth. So this was about the siege of Burg op Zoom, a town in
Holland, the advancing Spanish armies, and how the Dutch managed to
fight them off so that the town never was taken. The
other melody, which wound up in Psalms, in a very doleful setting about
how glory has departed and they have been
plundered; the godless have taken over everything, and our temple lays
disgraced — you know, one of these real downers! The original
words were something like “Oh, merry month of May! Everything is
green and beautiful and the birds
are singing all night and all day, and I am going to the tavern and
have something wonderful to drink and to toast my sweetheart,” and so
forth! [Both laugh]
JC:
Music is
like any other thing. It
can be used for so many different reasons. It’s up to the user to
decide what it should be used for. A person who supplies beer,
let’s say, once the beer
has left the supermarket, the seller has no control
anymore over what happens to the beer. It will reach somebody’s
home. That person may drink only one can of beer per night, or
maybe only one can per week, or he may elect to down an
entire six-pack all in one sitting. That’s his privilege.
Whether it’s good or bad judgment to do something is up
to the users. It’s that way with art, also. You can abuse
art by using it
in such a way as to hurt yourself. Don Quixote did, reading all
of these historical romances! He read so many of
them in such fast succession that he went bonkers and turned into the
kind of character that people refer to today as “quixotic,”
not really of
this world, doing things that to the rest of the world seem ridiculous
or irrational. Most creative people in this
particular time and place are doing their artistic thing as a labor of
love. They don’t really expect that they can make a living from
it, but they go on doing it anyway because each of them feels a
calling; he feels there is something where he must do this. It
will not let him go. For a creative person, when something calls,
you
really cannot tell it to go away. When I wrote that opera, I
was in the grip of something that I was unable to shake off
until I sat down and took out pencil and paper and dealt with
it.
BD: I’m
an
old bassoon
player, so I listened to that first and it was a lot of fun.
JC:
Yes, I am, because from what I’ve seen after all
of these years, I believe that there is always going to be someone who
will feel that it’s important to write for people in general, and not
just for the elect or for whoever is up there on a pedestal. In
the old days, there were composers who wrote only for the church or
only for the nobility, and since that was the only patron or customer
out there, they didn’t really bother to think very much about the other
people. But we’re in a different era now, and one has to
consider the other people that are out there. I also think
that there’s a question of altruism. Every
composer should ask himself at one point or another, “Who
am I writing
for? Am I writing just for myself? Am I not writing for
other
people as well as for myself? The world gave me things. I
have been eating and drinking all of these years because of the bounty
of the earth, or of my fellow men. What am I giving back to
them? Is it enough just to accept a weekly paycheck and not give
anything more?”
It’s like people who have been asked
to give to some worthy charity, and they say, “Why pick on me? I
earn my living. I’ve already paid my dues.” There is a
philosophical question in there, whether you use such a
phrase or not. I think it’s important. Unless you are
sacrificing yourself, which I don’t
think anybody should willingly do, I think that people should try to
leave the earth having given back maybe a little bit more than they
took.
JC: That
is
the most difficult question for any
composer. The important thing about writing a piece of music is
to know, or to realize, not what to include, but what to leave
out. You have to be willing to cut mercilessly. It doesn’t
matter whether you’re writing words or music, or what the situation
is. It’s better to be too short than too long. It’s better
to be Franz Berwald than Gustav Mahler. Various commissions since the time of the
interview...Piano Concerto, commissioned by the Argentine pianist Mirian Conti; Violin Concerto, commissioned and performed by the American violinist Eric Grossman; Trumpet Concerto, commissioned by trumpeter Jeffrey Silberschlag; Clarinet Concerto #1; Evocations (Clarinet Concerto #2); these and other works for clarinet commissioned and performed by John Manasse; [It was the first Clarinet Concerto which precipitated Jim's visit to Ostend Belgium where he wrote Caprice for the Claribel Clarinet Choir in Ostend in 1997, which was the foundation for a great friendship between Maestro Guido Six, which resulted in the commission in February of 2010 for Texas Suite for future performance at the TMEA in San Antonio]; A Grecian Festival for the Laurel Ensemble, based in California [see photo below]; Trio No. 2 for Piano, Violin and Cello, commissioned by Sigma Alpha Iota and given its world premiere at Sigma Alpha Iota’s Convention [see photo below in next box]; Three Dances for Clarinet and Guitar, commissioned by Raphael Sanders and David Galvez; Mozart Fantasy, Fiesta Latina and Dance of Praise, commissioned by the Quintet of the Americas; The Empty Platter (from a poem by Ogden Nash) and Three Bon-Bons for the New York Treble Singers;
Fantasy
on Two Asian Folk Songs for Flute/Oboe
and Orchestra for
Jeffrey Liang & the Chinese Youth Orchestra; Sonata for Violin & Piano,
commissioned by Kees Kooper, the
renowned Dutch Violinist.
![]() ![]() |
| JAMES
COHN was born in 1928 in Newark, New Jersey, and took violin and
piano lessons there. Later he studied composition with Roy Harris,
Wayne Barlow and Bernard Wagenaar, and majored in Composition at
Juilliard, graduating in 1950. He is married, and has lived and worked
for many years in New York City. He was initiated as a National Arts
Associate of Sigma Alpha Iota (International Music Fraternity) (SAI) in
the Tulsa Oklahoma chapter in 1998. He has written solo, chamber, choral and orchestral works, and his catalog includes 3 string quartets, 5 piano sonatas and 8 symphonies. Some have won awards, including a Queen Elisabeth of Belgium Prize for his Symphony No. 2 (premiered at Brussels) and an A.I.D.E.M. prize for his Symphony No. 4 (premiered in Florence at the Maggio Musicale). Paul Paray and the Detroit Symphony introduced the composer's Symphony No. 3 and Variations on "The Wayfaring Stranger", and his opera The Fall of the City received its premiere in Athens, Ohio after winning the Ohio University Opera Award. He has had many performances of his choral and chamber music, and world-wide use of his music commissioned for television and cinema. His most recent completed orchestral work is a Piano Concerto, commissioned by the Argentine pianist Mirian Conti, and his most recent chamber music work is the Trio No. 2 for Piano, Violin and Cello, commissioned by Sigma Alpha Iota and scheduled for premiere at Sigma Alpha Iota's annual Convention in the summer of 2006 at Orlando, Florida, [photo below] 3 Dances for Clarinet and Guitar, commissioned by Raphael Sanders and David Galvez and Duo for Clarinet & Violin, commissioned by Julianne Kirk and Adda Kridler. ![]() Commissions for other works have come from The McKim Fund in the Library of Congress (for the Concerto da camera for Violin, Piano and Wind Quintet), Pennsylvania's "Music At Gretna" festival (for the Mount Gretna Suite, for chamber orchestra), Jon Manasse (for the Concerto No. 1 for Clarinet and Strings), Christopher Jepperson (for 3 Evocations [Clarinet Concerto No. 2]), Jeffrey Silberschlag (for the Concerto for Trumpet and Strings) and Claribel (the Belgian 30-piece clarinet ensemble) (for the 3-movement suite Caprice). SOME WORDS FROM THE PRESS
"The highlight of the program was the first performance of three (choral) works by James Cohn, to texts by Ogden Nash. They proved to be indescribably funny, the poet's shrewdly nonsensical verses being set in a mock-heroic manner worthy of Sir Arthur Sullivan. The works, moreover, were effective in performance. Mr. Cohn has technical skill, an inventive musical imagination, a flair for setting text to music and a sense of humor. All these qualities are as rare as they are admirable, and it is hoped that Mr. Cohn will soon be heard from again." - THE NEW YORK TIMES "Mr. Cohn's opus (Variations on "The Wayfaring Stranger", premiered by Paul Paray and the Detroit Symphony) proved to be spectacularly appealing. Moreover it is melodic... The Variations run the gamut of human emotions with delightful solo lines... It was a superb performance of a superb work." - THE WINDSOR (ONT.) STAR "Cohn's Symphony (No. 3) is an eminently attractive one which makes its claim on the attention with the opening phrases and sustains the interest throughout the performance. There is an economy of means in the orchestration of the piece, but no yielding of inventiveness or imaginative composition. Indeed, the work throughout is marked strongly by individuality, and comes as a refreshing experience in modern music." - DETROIT FREE PRESS "I am an unabashed fan of the music of James Cohn... Thus I was excited by the prospect of a new clarinet concerto (No. 1)... and I was not disappointed. The piece is easily in a class with (Gerald) Finzi's concerto; it is melodic and charming, without sounding old-fashioned or stuffy... Cohn seems not to mind writing music that one can enjoy, and I applaud him for it." - AMERICAN RECORD GUIDE "Imagine: here is contemporary music that is easy to listen to and enjoyable... Cohn reminds me of (Jean) Francaix in his expert writing for wind instruments and for his infectious good humor and high spirits, and of Hindemith for his angular melodies. These comparisons are not meant to suggest that Cohn is not original, for he is... I would rank the Wind Quintet high on the long list of such works in the literature." - AMERICAN RECORD GUIDE "James Cohn's music is light and gay yet thoroughly classical; the wind music has something of the spirit of Parisian wind pieces, but with a distinctly American flavor. Chief characteristics are brevity, wit and clarity; Cohn's melodies are charming." - FANFARE "Witty and well-crafted music. Cohn's orchestral music is well structured, warmly tonal and rich in grace and wit" - GRAMOPHONE "The six works on this disk are high on charm and craftsmanship." - CLASSICS TODAY |
This interview was recorded in Chicago on October
19, 1987.
Portions (along with recordings)
were used on WNIB in 1991, 1993 and 1998, and on WNUR in 2006 and
2008. This
transcription was
made and posted on this
website in 2010.
Award - winning broadcaster Bruce Duffie was with WNIB, Classical 97 in Chicago from 1975 until its final moment as a classical station in February of 2001. His interviews have also appeared in various magazines and journals since 1980, and he now continues his broadcast series on WNUR-FM, as well as on Contemporary Classical Internet Radio.
You are invited to visit his website for more information about his work, including selected transcripts of other interviews, plus a full list of his guests. He would also like to call your attention to the photos and information about his grandfather, who was a pioneer in the automotive field more than a century ago. You may also send him E-Mail with comments, questions and suggestions.